And if that's not surprising enough, they also share the same name: Brady Feigl.
Both athletes tell Inside Edition they have never met anyone with their uncommon name.
They both stand at 6-foot-4 and are pitchers. They also have the same red hair, red beards and glasses.
One of the major differences is that one of the Bradys is left-handed, while the other one throws right-handed.
One Brady plays for a Single-A affiliate of the Oakland A’s while the other pitches for the Texas Rangers’ Triple-A club.
Inside Edition recently brought the pair together in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, where it was revealed they both underwent Tommy John surgery — performed by the same doctor.
One of the guy’s girlfriends wanted to meet her man’s so-called doppelganger in person and she claims she can tell them apart.
In the spirit of good sportsmanship, each athlete said the other is a better baseball player than themselves.