Mystery Surrounds Family Massacre at New Jersey Mansion Set Aflame

Playing

How did a family of four end up dead at their New Jersey mansion?

Businessman Keith Caneiro, 50, was found shot dead outside while the severely burned bodies of his wife, Jennifer Caneiro, 45, and their two children were found inside their $1.5 million Colts Neck home Tuesday, police said. The wife and children, whom authorities have tentatively identified as 11-year-old Jesse Caneiro and 8-year-old Sophia Caneiro, were reportedly stabbed, but it's not clear whether they died in the fire or from the apparent wounds.

Adding to the mystery, Keith's 51-year-old brother, Paul Caneiro, was charged Wednesday with aggravated arson for allegedly setting his own home, just miles away from his brother's, on fire with his wife and two daughters inside. No one was injured in that fire. 

Prosecutors allege Paul set his home alight early Tuesday "by using gasoline," according to a criminal complaint. He reportedly told firefighters the flames were triggered by a gas leak. Neighbors said Paul appeared distraught as he watched the house burn.

Officials would neither confirm nor deny whether Paul is a suspect in his brother's family's murders. 

Paul is listed as the vice president of Square One, a New York-based strategic technology consulting firm launched by his brother, Keith. Keith is listed as the firm’s CEO and chief technology officer. 

Colts Neck is a wealthy community that's home to a number of sprawling multimillion-dollar mansions, including that of Bruce Springsteen and several members of "The Real Housewives of New Jersey." Former "Daily Show" host Jon Stewart also owns an animal rescue center there. 

RELATED STORIES

Family Found Dead at Their Burning Home, Husband's Brother Arrested for Setting Separate Fire

Serial Killer Suspected in More Than 90 Murders Charged in 1994 Cold Case Killing

Ohio Parents and Sons 'Planned' Execution-Style Murders of 8 Members of Another Family: Cops