Up Next

    New Lifetime Movie Shares Story Of Mary Jo Buttafuoco

    January 15, 2026

    Amy Fisher, dubbed The Long Island Lolita, was 17 years old when she shot the wife of her 36-year-old boyfriend, Joey Buttafuoco in the face. Mary Jo Buttafuoco survived and Fisher was sentenced to five to 15 years in prison. Joey was sentenced for statutory rape. Inside Edition was there for every twist and turn in the saga. Now, Mary Jo's story is being retold from her point of view in a new Lifetime movie "I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco."

    Watch Live
    Inside Edition Streaming: Keep WatchingInside Edition Streaming: Keep Watching